Madison’s Pizza Cafe offers a casual and relaxed atmosphere well suited for all to relax and enjoy a fine experience in dining. The restaurant offers a broad menu from simple appetizers to full entrees and desserts. Madison’s Cafe has an intimate bar for those who wish to watch a game while snacking on a sampler or enjoying a cocktail. We offer cafe style dining, as well as a separate dining room for a more intimate experience, such as dinner for two, family gatherings, business meetings, parties or other special events. 

madisons pleasant valley chicken alf


Madison’s Pizza in Pleasant Valley, New York has consistently sustained our ongoing, excellent reputation of quality food at affordable prices. Owner Jason Kiggins opened the restaurant with the goal of creating a ‘small town pizza cafe’ vibe with a family friendly environment, combined with a more intimate dining experience. 

“It was important to me to give our town a place where folks could go to relax and enjoy great food without having to pay the high prices. We saw the need for providing a great pizza place, but we also wanted to provide a larger menu to encourage people to try different things each time they come in, and it’s been very successful. We are grateful for our loyal guests and we really wouldn’t change a thing. As long as they’re happy, I’m happy,” says Kiggins.     

Visit our Menu Page.


  • Mondays: Spaghetti & Meatballs or Sausage $5.95 all day
  • Tuesdays: Large Cheese Pizza  $9.25 all day
  • Everyday: Large Cheese Pizza, 2 Dozen Wings & 2 Liter Soda: $24.95

Not to be combined with any other offer

Call us at 845-635-9500 

Open 7 days a week!